Crewtide vs Spreadsheets

Crewtide vs planning routes in a spreadsheet

Most recurring service teams plan the week in Excel or Google Sheets, on a whiteboard and by phone. The software is free. The hours and the driving aren’t.

Updated October 30, 2026By the Crewtide team at Codified

The real cost

A spreadsheet costs nothing until you count the scheduler’s hours rebuilding the week and the drive time of routes nobody optimized. For a team running 10 routes, cutting drive time 15% and letting the week build itself is worth about $55,400 a year, against $7,428 a year for Crewtide Core.

Crewtide imports the same sheet, so trying it costs an afternoon.

What Crewtide is worth

For a team running 10 routes that builds them by hand today, optimized weekly routes and a week that builds itself are worth about $55,400 a year in technician time, fuel, vehicle wear and scheduling hours.

15 hoursless driving every week (15% of 100 drive hours)
$55,400saved a year at the calculator’s defaults
7.5×what Crewtide Core costs ($7,428 a year)

Your numbers will differ. Work out your savings with your routes, crew sizes, drive time and fuel price.

At a glance

Crewtide vs Spreadsheets for recurring routes (checked October 25, 2026)
What matters for recurring routesCrewtideSpreadsheets
Built forRecurring commercial service teams of about 5 to 100 technicians who plan the same customers every weekAnything. Most teams start here
Recurring visits generated from one customer listYesCustomer rules hold each visit cycle and usual days, and every week is generated from themPartlyCycles are flipped on and off by hand each week, or with formulas someone has to maintain
Plans a whole week across every technicianYesBuilding the week places every due visit on a route, with route optimization on every planNoYou place every visit yourself
Service windows per customerYesService windows and no-go times for each customerPartlyA column you have to remember to check
Crew size per visitYesTime on site set per crew sizePartlyA note in a cell
Shows what a move pushes back or bumps before you commitYesFind a spot ranks every option and shows what it pushes back or bumpsNoMoving a customer bumps someone else, found out later
Change log with a reason for every editYesEvery edit is logged with a reason, and undo works step by stepPartlyVersion history shows what changed, not why
List of customers to tell when a visit movesYesTo notify list with the old time, the new time and the reasonNoPhone calls from memory
Getting your data inYesImport customers from a spreadsheet; QuickBooks and Jobber sync are coming with ProYesIt is the data
Free trialYes14 days, no credit cardYesAlready open on your screen
Published priceCore from $189 a month for up to 3 routes, billed annually; $619 for up to 10 routes ($739 month to month). Pro coming soon$0 for the software; the cost is the scheduler’s hours and the driving
What you pay forRoutes on your busiest day, sold in sizes. Office users are freeExcel or Google Workspace licences you already have

What the weekly rebuild really costs

The rebuild usually looks like this: copy last week’s tab, mistakes included; flip every-other-week and monthly customers on and off; check time off, holidays and events across calendars, texts and memory; untangle conflicts where moving one customer bumps another; call every customer whose visit moved; then re-enter every change in the system the business runs on. One scheduler told us about 60% of their week went to that loop.

The same tasks, by hand and in Crewtide
TaskCrewtideSpreadsheet, whiteboard and phone
Recurring cadencesGenerated from one customer listFlipped on and off by hand every week
RoutesOptimized with real road times, inside every windowGuessed from memory and a map
Moving a customerFind a spot shows who moves and what breaks firstBumps someone else, found out later
ConflictsFlagged live; red must be fixedFound by crews in the field
Customer noticesA To notify list with the old time, new time and reasonOne phone call at a time
The recordEvery change logged with a reason; undo step by stepLives in one person’s head

Signs you’ve outgrown the sheet

  • The rebuild takes most of a day, every week.
  • Biweekly and monthly customers get missed or doubled.
  • Nobody else can build the week when the scheduler is out.
  • Customers find out about changes when the technician arrives.
  • Technicians drive past each other to reach customers on opposite sides of town.

Put your own numbers into the savings calculator to see what the sheet is costing you.

Keep the sheet as your master list

A clean sheet of customers, addresses, cycles, windows and time on site is exactly what Crewtide needs, so the work you’ve put into it carries over. Crewtide imports it, plans the week from it, and exports route sheets and change lists back to a spreadsheet after you publish.

Moving from your spreadsheet to Crewtide

  1. Tidy the master list.One row per customer with address, visit cycle, usual days, service window, no-go times, time on site and crew size. The free recurring schedule template has every column.
  2. Import it.Start the 14-day trial and import the sheet (Excel or CSV). See Excel or Google Sheets.
  3. Build next week and compare.Put it next to the week you built by hand: total drive time, visits that didn’t fit and conflicts.

Questions

Can you plan routes in Excel?

Yes, and many service teams start there. It gets slow and error-prone once cycles, service windows and crews interact across many technicians, and a spreadsheet can’t optimize the routes.

Is there a free route planner for Google Sheets?

Google Sheets can hold the plan, and add-ons can map addresses, but it won’t schedule recurring visits around windows and crews or optimize the routes. Crewtide imports your sheet and has a 14-day free trial.

How much does planning routes by hand cost?

For 10 routes, one technician each driving 2 hours a day, routes that run 15% longer than they need to cost about $23,250 a year in technician time, plus fuel and wear. Add the scheduler’s hours and the total is about $55,400 a year.

Do I have to give up my spreadsheet to use Crewtide?

No. Crewtide imports it, and you can export route sheets and change lists back to a spreadsheet after you publish the week.

Sources

Checked October 25, 2026. Plans and prices change; the vendor’s own page is the final word.

Plan next week in Crewtide.

Bring your customer list and build next week with route optimization. 14 days free, no credit card, no setup fee.